I was taking some yoga lessons at the health club and was having a smoothy in the juice bar they have afterwards and some of the other gym members were there and one came over to me. He was a really nice looking guy and in very good shape, a bit more muscular than I go for usually. We had a nice chat and afterwards he asked me out to dinner the next evening. I was looking for a boyfriend, so I wondered if this might be the opportunity I was waiting for.
We went out and had a nice evening and saw each other a couple of times over the next few weeks and finally I was ready to get close to him and the big night came when we were going to be intimate for the first time. I unzipped his pants and slid my hand inside and felt around…um, wtf? He grinned sheepishly and said his cock was a bit smaller than average.
He got undressed and I swear, that thing was pushing three inches on a good day. He said this had proven problematic a few times in his life before, but he hoped it wouldn’t make me not consider him. I didn’t know what to say. He was less than half the size of normal, I didn’t think I’d be able to deal with this and said I’d have to think about it, he said he was so horny, would I at least let him masturbate for me and watch? I reluctantly agreed and he sat on the edge of the bed and took that little things between his thumb and forefinger and started pumping it up and down and came in around two minutes. Oh boy, this cemented it. No thanks, I tried to be as diplomatic as I could, but I just couldn’t deal with a three inch two pump chump.